Agency and Power Across Biological Scales: A Framework for Cross-Scale Analysis
What's this about?
Power is control of controllers — the capacity to reliably steer another agent's action by acting on the variables that govern its action selection. This paper develops a graded framework for agency and power that applies uniformly from bacteria to human institutions.
Agency admits degrees: a system is an agent to the extent it maintains internal states representing self/environment and uses them to guide action selection. Power operates through two routes: representation-mediated (manipulating perception and values) and constraint/controller-hijack (limiting action sets or modifying control systems directly).
The same mechanisms trace continuously from quorum sensing in bacteria, through parasitic manipulation in insects, to prestige and coercion in human societies. "Demi-agents" like corporations present agent-like interfaces but outsource their decision-making to constituent minds.
Key findings
- •
Graded agency via code formation: explicit criteria distinguish agents from non-agents
- •
Two routes to power: representation-mediated vs constraint/controller-hijack
- •
Cross-scale continuity from bacteria → fungi → insects → primates → humans
- •
Demi-agents: entities that present agent-like interfaces but outsource cognition
Citation
Todd, I. (2025). Agency and Power Across Biological Scales: A Framework for Cross-Scale Analysis. Biology & Philosophy (submitted).
Workflow: Claude Code with Opus 4.5 (Anthropic) for drafting; GPT-5.2 (OpenAI) and Gemini 3 Pro (Google) for review. Author reviewed all content and takes full responsibility.