← Back to Papers
Under Review

Substrate Dimensionality in Neural Systems: Limits on Capability, Interpretability, and Consciousness

Biological Cybernetics (submitted) (2025)

What's this about?

AI may hit a hard capability ceiling because digital hardware has the wrong dimensionality — one global clock versus 101410^{14}101810^{18} continuous degrees of freedom in a biological brain.

Substrate Dimensionality in Neural Systems: Limits on Capability, Interpretability, and Consciousness

Modern AI achieves enormous algorithmic complexity, but it runs on substrates with essentially one degree of freedom: the global clock that synchronises all operations. Biological brains exploit vastly higher substrate dimensionality through asynchronous, continuous dynamics — every synapse, every dendritic branch, every ion channel is a semi-independent variable.

This dimensional mismatch may explain three stubborn problems. First, why AI plateaus: scaling parameters doesn't add substrate dimensions. Second, why AI resists interpretation: you can't reconstruct internal states when the system operates beyond your measurement capacity. The paper proves this "projection singularity" is a mathematical impossibility, not just a practical difficulty. Third, why AI may never achieve consciousness: subjective experience may require volumetric field coupling (continuous 3D dynamics), not just graph connectivity (discrete node-edge structures).

The implication is uncomfortable: we may already be approaching the ceiling of what digital hardware can achieve, regardless of how many parameters we add.

Key findings

  • Digital substrates have Dsubstrate1D_{\text{substrate}} \approx 1; biological brains have 1014\sim 10^{14}101810^{18} degrees of freedom

  • Projection singularity: a fundamental impossibility for interpreting systems beyond measurement capacity

  • Three substrate classes with distinct capability ceilings

  • Consciousness may require volumetric field coupling, not just graph connectivity

Citation

Todd, I. (2025). Substrate Dimensionality in Neural Systems: Limits on Capability, Interpretability, and Consciousness. Biological Cybernetics (submitted).

Workflow: Claude Code with Opus 4.5 (Anthropic) for drafting and simulation code; Gemini 3 Pro (Google) and GPT-5.2 (OpenAI) for review. Author reviewed all content and takes full responsibility.